🍰 12 Bakeries Crafting Irresistible Holiday Pies & Treats

Celebrate the season by supporting local bakeries in Fairfield County—each one a standout for holiday pies, festive pastries, and unique gifts. We’ve rounded up 12 favorite spots; click each venue name for their website or map.

1. Alina’s Cakes & Cookies – Fairfield & Westport

With locations at 2480 Black Rock Turnpike (Fairfield) and 1252 Post Rd E (Westport), Alina’s blends comfort desserts with elegant gourmet cakes and pastries. (Alina's Cakes and Cookies)
Great for custom holiday cakes and pies—plus cookies to gift.

2. Silverman’s Farm Market – Easton

451 Sport Hill Road, Easton. A farm-market experience with full bakery section, daily baked pies, and holiday-pie pre-orders. (Silvermans Farm)
Ideal for holiday pie pickups and family visits.

3. Oronoque Farms Gift & Bakery – Shelton

While a direct website link wasn’t located, Oronoque Farms is listed in pie round-ups for the region.
This is a strong candidate for your “Holiday Pie” list if you wish to include Bakeries beyond the major towns.

4. Isabelle et Vincent – Fairfield

1903 Post Rd, Fairfield. A Paris-style bakery offering breads, croissants, pastries, and seasonal desserts. (Isabelle et Vincent)
Perfect for elegant holiday brunch pastries or gift-boxes.

5. The Pantry – Fairfield

While we couldn’t locate a full dedicated bakery website, The Pantry appears in local holiday-pie summaries. Worth calling for holiday-pie availability in Fairfield.

6. Kneads Bakery Café & Mill – Westport

580 Riverside Ave, Westport. Family-run bakery-café and flour mill, offering fresh breads and pastries daily. (kneadsbakerycafe.com)
Great stop for artisan bread to accompany your holiday meal.

7. Beldotti Bakery – Stamford

605 Newfield Ave, Stamford. Scratch breads, cakes, pastries and holiday-dessert staples. (beldottibakery.com)
A go-to for Stamford area dessert trays and pies.

8. Michele’s Pies – Norwalk

666 Main Ave, Norwalk. Known for award-winning pies; offers shipping as well as local pick-up. (Michele's Pies)
A standout for pumpkin, pecan, apple pies with serious pedigree.

9. Whistle Stop Bakery – Ridgefield

20 Portland Ave (Branchville RR Station), Ridgefield. Seasonal pies, cakes, and gluten-free options. (Whistle Stop Bakery)
Ideal for special-diet holiday options.

10. Sweet Pea’s Baking Company – Old Greenwich

212 Sound Beach Ave, Old Greenwich. Fresh-roasted coffee + pastries; a warm local café vibe. (Sweet Pea's Baking)
Perfect for holiday morning stop-by or pastry trays for guests.

11. DiMare Pastry Shop – Stamford

Stamford location (and Riverside). Italian-style desserts, cakes, cookies, pies. (dimarepastry.com)
Great for large parties + traditional holiday dessert assortments.

12. Scratch Baking – Milford

84 Broad Street, Milford. Artisanal breads, scones, pies, and sweets made in-house from real ingredients. (Scratch Baking)
Worth the short drive for authentic craft bakery holiday items.

Supporting local businesses keeps community charm strong and ensures great-quality treats. 

Ordering early helps secure holiday pies and custom desserts—many of these spots pre-order weeks in advance.